Brian Buckle denied compensation after wrongful conviction

Brian Buckle, who spent five years in prison for crimes he did not commit, has been denied compensation by the Ministry of Justice (MoJ). Despite the Court of Appeal determining his conviction unsafe in 2023, Buckle learned that he does not meet the requirements for compensation. The 51-year-old was convicted in 2017 of indecent assault and attempted rape against a child. With the help of new evidence and witnesses, his legal team successfully argued for a retrial, where he was found not guilty. However, the MoJ claims he has not proven his innocence well enough to receive any payments. Buckle shared his emotional reaction to the MoJ's decision in an interview. He expressed disbelief and sadness, stating he feels like he has lost five years of his life, along with his job and pension. His wife Elaine has supported him throughout this ordeal. The Ministry of Justice has acknowledged the serious impact of wrongful convictions but emphasizes the strict proof requirements for compensation claims. Since a legal change in 2014, those seeking compensation must demonstrate their innocence, which few have succeeded in doing. Critics argue this system is unfair and inhumane, preventing many from receiving justice. The Law Commission is currently reviewing the compensation process, and recommendations are expected in 2026.