Bronx Judge Jeffrey Zimmerman resigns after misconduct investigation

A judge in the Bronx, Jeffrey Zimmerman, has announced his resignation from the bench effective April 3. This decision comes after an investigation by the New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct, which accused him of a "pattern of discourteous behavior" and criticizing a jury's verdict. In a letter to Chief Administrative Judge Joseph Zayas, Zimmerman confirmed he would step down without attempting to return to his position. In exchange, the commission dropped its investigation into his conduct. Since 2003, this agreement has been reached 148 times regarding judges in similar situations. Zimmerman's attorney, Deborah Scalise, highlighted that there were no findings of wrongdoing against him and emphasized his extensive professional background, which includes 41 years as a prosecutor and seven years as a judge. However, he faced allegations of misconduct starting in January. Specific complaints include Zimmerman interfering with a defendant's attorney and making inappropriate comments about a jury's decision. He also reportedly disparaged other judges in two instances, failing to maintain the expected standard of patience and courtesy in court. Judges have a responsibility to be respectful to all parties in court, as stated by Commissioner Robert Tembeckjian. Zimmerman expressed gratitude for his service as a judge but has been a controversial figure. He has been critical of New York's bail reform laws and had previously made headlines for requiring COVID-19 vaccinations for defendants in plea deals.