Calls for independent bail assessments for NSW police

Concerns have been raised regarding the bail process for New South Wales (NSW) Police officers charged with domestic violence offences. A former magistrate believes the decision to grant bail should be made independently from police. David Heilpern, who served as a magistrate for over 20 years, says there is a conflict of interest when police decide on bail for their colleagues. He suggests that charges, especially those related to domestic violence, should be handled by an independent body like the Director of Public Prosecutions. Heilpern emphasized the need for protection for victims during the period between an investigation and court proceedings. From January 1, 2023, to early March 2025, 42 NSW Police officers have been charged with domestic violence-related offences. Out of these, 10 were refused bail, 14 were granted conditional police bail, and 18 were issued future court attendance notices without any conditions. NSW Police stated that officers charged are treated like any other community members and that their bail conditions follow the law. One particular case involved officer Reuben Timperley, who has been charged with multiple offences related to domestic violence. He was released on a court attendance notice with no bail conditions and has been suspended without pay. Heilpern described this outcome as "extraordinary," noting the seriousness of the charges. Another officer, a senior constable, also faced similar charges but received a future court attendance notice with no bail conditions. The employment status of both officers is currently under review. The NSW Police Commissioner, Karen Webb, did not dismiss the possibility of changing the bail process. She stated that they need to apply existing laws but remain open to considerations for adjustments. Meanwhile, Attorney-General Michael Daley has not commented on potential changes to the bail system. Heilpern insists that independent assessments are essential, particularly in the early stages of the judicial process, as the time following a domestic violence charge is crucial for victim safety. He argues that individuals should receive equal treatment, regardless of their profession. Karen Bevan, CEO of Full Stop Australia, echoed concerns about the need for public confidence in police handling of domestic violence cases. She emphasized the critical need for safety and proper processes to manage any conflicts of interest effectively. Victims or survivors of domestic violence involving police officers deserve to have their concerns addressed. The safety of these individuals should remain the top priority as the community expects fair and transparent processes within the judicial system.