Claude outperformed ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity in search
A recent comparison tested four leading AI chatbots: ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, and Perplexity. The focus was on their search capabilities. Each chatbot was assessed for how well it answered specific questions about topics like space news, population data, cultural events, weather, and film reviews. In the first test about a NASA press release, each chatbot had a different approach. ChatGPT provided a brief answer, while Gemini offered a detailed bullet-point list. Claude gave a more essay-like response. Perplexity's answer was well-structured, listing facts with citations, which was found to be the most helpful. Next, when asked about Auckland's current population, Perplexity and ChatGPT provided the same figure, while Claude and Gemini reported a slightly lower number. Claude's narrative response included extra details, which were appreciated. A challenging question about events in Vancouver revealed different strengths. Claude and Perplexity gave accurate event lists, but Gemini avoided directly answering, suggesting strategies to find information instead. ChatGPT provided an overview with essential details and links. For weather forecasts in Tokyo, Claude offered a summary, but others excelled visually. Perplexity presented a temperature line graph, and Gemini included a colorful graphic that was easy to understand. Finally, for reviews of the latest Paddington film, Claude produced the best summary, blending critics' opinions into a coherent narrative. Gemini and Perplexity leaned toward list-making, while ChatGPT's response was lengthier but less refined. Overall, the rankings suggested that each chatbot has unique strengths. Gemini ranked lowest, mainly due to its poor event response. ChatGPT came in third, often being too brief. Perplexity provided helpful details but resembled a search engine. Surprisingly, Claude topped the list for its cohesive narrative style and thorough answers, making it a compelling option for users willing to pay for premium access.