Homeowner fined $10,150 after dispute with HOA president

A homeowner in Georgia is facing a surprising $10,150 fine from his homeowners' association (HOA) after a dispute. John Coleman claims that the fine is a retaliatory measure by HOA president Melanie Downing. Their conflict escalated over property line issues, which involved police intervention. Coleman has expressed that the situation has caused significant stress for him and his family, even leading to hospitalizations. Coleman is not alone in his concerns. Many residents in the Greighfield community, located east of Atlanta, are worried about rising fines and HOA fees, which have increased dramatically this year. The HOA fees rose from $745 in 2022 to $1,316 in 2023, leading residents to question the board's financial management. During this time, another homeowner received a puzzling debt collection notice totaling $137,768, raising more concerns about the HOA's practices. Many residents fear that the rising fines could lead to foreclosure on their homes. Georgia law states that unpaid fines exceeding $2,000 can result in serious legal actions, including liens. At a recent meeting, Downing warned homeowners about possible fines if they did not follow new property rules. However, she claimed to be exempt from some of these regulations herself. Residents have attempted to change the HOA leadership by voting for a new board. Despite this, Downing has refused to acknowledge the results. Homeowners are now seeking court action for a financial audit and to have their voices heard. Meanwhile, the HOA has hired a law firm to assist with debt collections. This situation highlights ongoing tensions regarding the power and governance of HOAs. In January 2025, state lawmakers proposed a bill to increase oversight of HOA activities, but it did not progress. Meanwhile, the residents in Greighfield continue to fight for their rights and clarity on the management of their community.