Humby trial delayed due to defense information requests

Tony Humby's trial, originally set to start 16 days ago, is still delayed. Uncertainty surrounds when the first witnesses will take the stand. The latest postponement follows applications from both the Crown and defence lawyers for more information. On Wednesday, Humby, in metal shackles, appeared in St. John's provincial court. He passed by witnesses who would testify against him, who remained outside the courtroom. Crown prosecutor Deidre Badcock expressed frustration with the delays, stating that "delay is the enemy of justice." The pause in proceedings is due to defence lawyer Mark Gruchy asking the Crown for additional information, believing it could help prove Humby's innocence. Meanwhile, Badcock has filed an application to dismiss the defence's requests, arguing the information won’t change anything. Gruchy insists that the disclosed documents could be vital for Humby's case. He is seeking a hearing to explore if similar evidence exists. The dispute involves documents accidentally shared with the defence, which Badcock wants to keep confidential. Gruchy's second request concerns a police file related to a break-in at Humby's residence after his April 2023 arrest, before police secured the property. Judge Rolf Pritchard is expected to decide Thursday on whether to dismiss Gruchy's applications. If the judge dismisses the motions, the trial could begin immediately. If he allows the defence to proceed, it may take weeks to gather necessary records and testimonies. Humby's trial is scheduled for a total of seven weeks, with 72 charges including alleged sexual exploitation of 11 youths. The complainants claim he groomed them with drugs and money. He is also facing additional charges of child trafficking. Humby is accused alongside his neighbor, Bruce Escott, who recently pleaded guilty and received a 13-year prison sentence.