Joe Amabile and Serena Pitt want Jason Tartick on Paradise

Joe Amabile and Serena Pitt are hoping to see Jason Tartick join the cast of "Bachelor in Paradise." At the 2025 iHeartRadio Music Awards, Serena expressed her belief that Jason would be a great addition. However, she is unsure if he would actually participate. Joe Amabile echoed her sentiments, saying he would love to see Jason find love in Mexico. Another Bachelor alum, Blake Horstmann, also shared his thoughts. He thinks it would be fun for Jason to join, but doubts he would take that step. Jason Tartick first appeared on the 14th season of "The Bachelorette" in 2018 but did not find love with Becca Kufrin. He began dating Kaitlyn Bristowe in 2019, but their engagement ended in August 2023 after four years together. Despite his breakup, Jason moved on with influencer Kat Stickler in April 2024, but that relationship also ended in October. Meanwhile, Joe and Serena have built a strong relationship since meeting on "Bachelor in Paradise" in 2021. The couple married in October 2022 and had a second ceremony in September 2023. Serena and Joe also suggested that Andrew Spencer and Greg Grippo could be good candidates for the show. They would be excited to see both men if they are single. When asked if they would consider appearing on the show again, the couple indicated they would be open to it. Joe advised new contestants to relax and enjoy the experience, while Serena encouraged single people to consider giving the show a try, reflecting on their own successful experience.