Judge Licitra criticized for freeing violent offenders in NYC

Queens Criminal Court Judge Wanda Licitra has been criticized for consistently releasing violent offenders. According to reports, she lets 85% of defendants go free, the highest rate among city judges handling similar cases. Sources describe Licitra’s approach as focused solely on the defendant. A Queens District Attorney insider stated, "She has no concern whatsoever for victims of crimes." This attitude was exemplified in a sex-crime case where Licitra allegedly spoke condescendingly to the victim, leading the woman to refuse to testify again. Licitra's conduct reportedly affects not just victims but also prosecutors. Critics say she is disrespectful and condescending towards them while showing more favor toward defense attorneys. In a notable instance, a prosecutor waited two hours to speak with Licitra but was ultimately ignored. In a 2024 assault case, Licitra dismissed evidence including video footage of a suspect attacking a pilot on a bus. The prosecutor explained this was a serious issue for public safety, but Licitra was not swayed. The suspect received minimal time in custody, only to be arrested again shortly after his release. Even other defense attorneys have noted her pattern of freeing accused violent criminals. Licitra has released multiple defendants without bail who later committed new violent offenses. Her decisions have sparked significant concern within the legal community about the implications for victims and public safety. Licitra has not publicly addressed these criticisms.