"When Hope Calls" Season 2 features a significant plot inconsistency

"When Hope Calls" Season 2 will premiere on April 6, 2025, featuring new leads Nora and Michael. However, a plot inconsistency has emerged, as Cindy Busby, who plays Nora, previously portrayed a character in "When Calls the Heart." Fans have noted that this creates a conflict within the shared universe of the two shows. Discussions on social media highlight the confusion over having two characters played by the same actress in the same storyline. Despite this issue, the new season promises family-oriented fun and romance, as teased by actor Christopher Russell. The trailer for the season was released on February 28.